An Empty Conservative or a Critical Theorist?

I missed this discussion when it happened in February, 2015, but as the MOA exists to promote critical discussion, as well as knowledge, of Oakeshott’s thought, I thought it was still worth sharing, now that I’ve found it!

Is Oakeshott an “empty conservative”, as Jason Kuznicki suggests at Clown Town.

Or is he perhaps a critical theorist, as Adam Gurri argues on Sweet Talk Conversation?